9 Questions to Ask When Buying a Business: 2026 Checklist
9 Questions to Ask When Buying a Business: 2026 Checklist

You found a business that looks profitable on the one-page listing. The owner is easy to like, the margins look tidy, and you are a signature away from a letter of intent. Then the hard questions start. Weeks later you learn the owner closed most of the sales personally, two customers produced about half the revenue, and the landlord will not assign the lease unless you sign a new personal guarantee. The price you shook hands on no longer matches the business you would own.
That sequence is ordinary on Main Street, and it is avoidable. The questions to ask when buying a business below are the order I use with buyers who are about to commit time and earnest money. Each one names the document or conversation that answers it, the red flag that should slow you down, and the deal term that can protect you if the answer is messy.
Start with the seller's story and the tax returns. Those checks are cheap. Save a full earnings review and a contract-by-contract legal read for businesses that survive the first pass. If a seller wants you to skip that order, treat the rush itself as information.
Table of Contents
- 1. Why Is the Owner Selling, and What Is Their Real Exit Timeline?
- 2. Do the Reported Financials Reflect True Earnings? (Quality of Earnings Review)
- 3. How Concentrated Is Revenue Among Customers, Suppliers, and Products?
- 4. How Dependent Is the Business on the Owner?
- 5. Will Key Employees Stay, and Is Management Capable of Running the Business?
- 6. What Is the Normalized Working Capital Requirement?
- 7. What Debts, Liabilities, and Contingent Obligations Come With the Business?
- 8. Are Contracts, Leases, Licenses, and Permits Transferable, and How Should the Deal Be Structured?
- 9. Is the Business's Market Position and Competitive Outlook Sustainable?
- Nine Buyer Questions at a Glance
- Turn These Nine Answers Into a Go or No-Go Decision
1. Why Is the Owner Selling, and What Is Their Real Exit Timeline?
The paper that matters here is thin. What you need is a direct conversation, written up the same day, set next to the broker's listing history.
Ask, "Walk me through what led you to decide to sell." Then ask how long they have considered it, whether the business was listed before, and why earlier buyers walked. Put that story beside three years of monthly revenue, margin, and headcount.
Say the seller describes a calm retirement, but sales have slid for a year and a half and two salespeople have already left. You are not looking at a lifestyle exit. You may be buying a book of customers that is already leaking, or a competitive problem the owner does not want to fight.
Practical rule: If the spoken reason and the trend lines disagree, believe the trend lines until the seller proves otherwise.
A few checks keep this from staying a story.
- Prior listings: Ask, where the broker allows it, why earlier deals died and whether the price was cut each time.
- Timeline pressure: A close demanded in two weeks is a red flag, not a courtesy.
- LOI protection: Keep a real exclusivity window, and reserve the right to walk if the reason does not match the books.
I would not waive diligence to meet a seller's clock. A repeated listing with serial price cuts usually means buyer fatigue, not a hidden bargain.
2. Do the Reported Financials Reflect True Earnings? (Quality of Earnings Review)
Headline profit is a claim. The proof is a three-way match of tax returns, management accounts, and bank deposits, month by month, for at least three years, plus current interim results.
Build your own adjusted-earnings schedule. Have the seller document every add-back: owner pay above a replacement manager, personal expenses, one-time costs, and related-party items. A vehicle "used for the business" that also carries the family on weekends is a common one. Pull it out and the multiple applies to a smaller number. If accrual revenue does not show up as deposits, stop and ask why before you debate price.
For SBA-financed acquisitions at or above the reported $3 million threshold, Barnes Dennig's note on the new SBA quality-of-earnings requirements says an independent review is expected to test whether earnings are reliable and sustainable, including cash proof and customer concentration. Below that size I still want the same logic, even if you do the first pass yourself and hire a transaction accountant only if the gaps are material. A practical walk-through of what to request sits in our guide to assessing seller financial disclosures.
Agree in writing whether price is based on seller's discretionary earnings or adjusted EBITDA. Mixed definitions are how two people "agree" on a multiple and still argue at closing. Unsupported add-backs should cut the price, sit in a holdback, or end the deal. They are not a footnote.
3. How Concentrated Is Revenue Among Customers, Suppliers, and Products?
Ask for a customer-level sales and gross-profit file for three years, tied back to the general ledger, invoices, or merchant deposits. Revenue share alone misleads you. A large, low-margin account can matter less than a smaller one that produces cash.
A customer at 15% to 20% of revenue is materially riskier when the owner is the only person that account will take a call from, which is the point Fornero Legal's acquisition diligence checklist makes when it pushes buyers to test who really holds the relationship. Say one retailer is nearly half of a distributor's sales and the contract renews four months after closing. That is not a footnote for the memo. It is a reason to reprice the deal or to make part of the price contingent on that renewal.
The red flag is a seller who will not name the relationship owner, will not allow a structured customer call, or cannot show churn and open complaints. Concentration in one supplier, one marketplace, or one license is the same risk wearing different clothes.
What the contract should do with a fragile account
- Earn-out or escrow: Tie a slice of price to renewal, collections, or retention, with the accounting method defined in advance.
- Seller note: Keep the seller paid over time so a lost account is not only your problem.
- Introductions: Put named customer meetings and a transition calendar into the purchase agreement, not a handshake.
Price concentration on gross profit, then decide whether you still want the business if the top account leaves in month three.
4. How Dependent Is the Business on the Owner?
Have the seller list every task they do in a normal week and name the person who could do it next month. That one-page list beats a polished org chart. If the owner is the estimator, the closer, and the only one who knows the vendor passwords, you are buying a job with debt attached.
Recent Main Street data in the 2025 Q4 Market Pulse Report indicates sellers commonly receive roughly 76% to 89% of deal value in cash at closing, while earn-outs and retained equity are used less often. Once that cash hits, goodwill is a weak incentive. I want the unpaid piece still outstanding while customers are being handed off.
Say a service firm's owner holds most of the client relationships. A paid consulting period with no metric is a vacation. Better: a defined 90-day plan, joint customer meetings, and a slice of price paid only if named accounts stay and keep paying. If the technical skill can be hired, hire the certified lead before you close, and confirm they will start.
Ask which decisions still require the owner and which knowledge is only in their head. Undocumented pricing rules and "call me if it breaks" processes are the red flag. Tie the seller note so verified transition failures can offset what you still owe.
5. Will Key Employees Stay, and Is Management Capable of Running the Business?
People risk shows up in a roster, not a culture slide. Ask for tenure, role, pay, and who holds the institutional knowledge, within privacy and confidentiality limits. Then meet the people who would still be there if the owner left on Friday.
The office manager who alone knows the bank logins, the vendor portals, and the payroll calendar is a single point of failure. So is a head machinist with no backup and no employment agreement. Change-of-control clauses and promised severance can also turn a "simple" deal into a cash surprise on day one.
A manufacturing buyer who locks retention bonuses for the production supervisor and the lead technician before closing is doing the expensive part early, on purpose. Waiting until after the announcement usually means you are bidding against the employee's fear.
Retention terms that actually hold
- Bonus design: Pay a retention bonus at 6 and 12 months, or at 12 and 24, only if the person is still in the role.
- Access plan: Move passwords, bank authority, and vendor contacts into company control at closing, with two people trained.
- Message: Tell key staff, with the seller present, what their job will be. Silence is how rumors start.
Our notes on employee retention strategies after an acquisition are the checklist I want a first-time buyer to use before they promise the seller that "the team will be fine." If the only manager is the seller, price a replacement into the offer now.
6. What Is the Normalized Working Capital Requirement?
Working capital is the cash the business needs to run next month: receivables and inventory, minus payables and the other current items you agree to count. Sellers can make the closing balance look healthy by chasing invoices hard or by letting bills pile up. You then fund the hole.
A short briefing on why the peg matters is worth watching before you draft the definition.
Calculate a trailing-twelve-month average and propose that average as the peg. If delivered working capital is short, the price drops dollar for dollar. Say the seller collected aggressively for sixty days before closing. The books look flush, and the first payroll plus restocked inventory empties the account. That is a purchase-price adjustment, not "normal seasonality," unless the historical months prove it.
Define the formula in the letter of intent, not the night before closing. State whether cash, debt, and accrued liabilities are in or out. Do a physical inventory count and an aged-receivables review. Old stock priced at full cost is not working capital you can spend. A deeper plain-language pass is in what working capital actually is.
If the business is seasonal, size a line of credit before you close. Discovering the slow month after you have already paid the seller is how buyers end up funding operations with a personal card.
7. What Debts, Liabilities, and Contingent Obligations Come With the Business?
Ask for a written list of every obligation, then test it. The list should cover bank loans, equipment finance, unpaid taxes, lawsuits, warranty claims, and anything the seller calls "not really a liability."
Order UCC, tax, litigation, and judgment searches in every state where the business operates or owns assets. A search that finds an equipment lender's lien on assets you thought were free is not a paperwork quibble. That lien gets paid at closing, or you do not close. The same is true of sales tax from prior years. Make the seller keep that liability, back it with indemnity, and hold cash in escrow so you are not chasing a seller who has already moved on.
Have the seller certify that the disclosure schedule is complete. Pair that certificate with a survival period and a cap you can collect against. An indemnity against a seller with no remaining note and no escrow is a polite letter.
Three buckets, decided before you sign
- Paid at close: Debt you will not assume, including liens the search turns up.
- Left with the seller: Known tax, legal, and warranty items you refuse to inherit.
- Unknowns: A holdback for a defined period, released only if claims do not appear.
If the seller will not sign the certificate, assume the list is incomplete. I treat that refusal as a reason to cut price sharply or to leave, not as a negotiation style.
8. Are Contracts, Leases, Licenses, and Permits Transferable, and How Should the Deal Be Structured?
You can buy the equipment and still fail to buy the business. Read every lease, customer contract, franchise agreement, software license, and permit for assignment and change-of-control language. A restaurant landlord who demands a new personal guarantee before approving the assignment has just changed your risk, even if the rent looks fine. Start consent requests early. Regulators and landlords do not run on your closing calendar.
Confirm the legal owner of the domain, marketplace account, and social logins. If those sit in the seller's personal name, write the transfer sequence into the closing checklist so a shop does not go dark between Friday and Monday.
Structure follows what diligence found. Many smaller deals are asset purchases, so you take named assets and named liabilities, not the whole history of the entity. Small Business Trends' summary of BizBuySell's Q3 2023 Insight Report notes that typical seller financing represented 10% to 20% of the purchase price over five to ten years. That note is useful as a bridge, and more useful if missed transition steps or undisclosed claims can offset what you still owe.
Terms to lock before the LOI hardens
- Consents: Lease, key vendors, and permits as closing conditions, not best efforts.
- Holdback: Cash held for a defined claim window when tax or contract risk is open.
- Non-compete: Scope and length a court where you operate will enforce.
- Financing: Your loan contingency timed so a slow lender does not kill a deal you still want.
Bring an M&A lawyer and a tax advisor in before the LOI, not after you have already promised a structure you cannot live with.
9. Is the Business's Market Position and Competitive Outlook Sustainable?
Past profit is not a forecast. Read reviews, competitor prices, and what suppliers say is happening to volume in this trade. Then run the model with lower demand and thinner margins, not only with the seller's last twelve months.
Sector moves are a reminder that last year's multiple can age quickly. In BizBuySell's 2025 third-quarter Insight Report, service businesses saw an 8% year-over-year decline in median sale price to $300,000, with a 15% decline in median cash flow, while retail's median sale price was $237,000, down 5%. A buyer's question is narrower than the market headline. Why would this company's cash flow hold up if wages rise, a regional competitor opens two towns over, or a key input gets more expensive?
A print shop with a long, steady drop in demand is a different purchase from a local service firm with repeat customers, a real switching cost, and a niche a bigger rival does not want. The first may still be buyable. It should not be priced as if the last good year repeats forever.
If the only advantage is "the owner knows everyone," you are back to owner dependence, and the price should move. I would rather pay a fair number for boring, repeatable demand than a hopeful number for a business that needs the market to cooperate.
Nine Buyer Questions at a Glance
| Item | Diligence Focus | Documents to Request | Common Red Flag | Best Reviewer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Why Is the Owner Selling, and What Is Their Real Exit Timeline? | Seller motivation, listing history, transition availability, and consistency with business performance | Listing and offer history, transition plan, revenue and margin trends | Repeated failed listings or a stated retirement reason that conflicts with declining performance | Buyer or M&A advisor |
| Do the Reported Financials Reflect True Earnings? (Quality of Earnings Review) | Verify revenue, expenses, add-backs, and repeatable earnings | Financial statements, tax returns, bank statements, sales ledgers | Earnings or add-backs do not reconcile to tax filings or bank deposits | Transaction-focused accountant |
| How Concentrated Is Revenue Among Customers, Suppliers, and Products? | Reliance on key customers, suppliers, products, or sales channels | Customer sales reports, contracts, supplier agreements, channel data | One customer, supplier, product, or platform accounts for a large share | Commercial diligence advisor |
| How Dependent Is the Business on the Owner? | Transferability of relationships, operating knowledge, and decision-making | Organization chart, operating procedures, task list, transition plan | Owner controls key relationships or operations with little documentation | Operations advisor |
| Will Key Employees Stay, and Is Management Capable of Running the Business? | Management depth, critical skills, retention, compensation, and employment obligations | Organization chart, compensation records, employment agreements, benefits details | Critical knowledge or access is held by one employee who may leave | HR or people diligence specialist |
| What Is the Normalized Working Capital Requirement? | Normal operating levels for receivables, inventory, payables, and seasonal cash needs | Aged receivables and payables, inventory reports, monthly balance sheets | Seller has accelerated collections, delayed payables, or overstated inventory | Transaction-focused accountant |
| What Debts, Liabilities, and Contingent Obligations Come With the Business? | Debt, taxes, litigation, liens, and other assumed or contingent obligations | Debt schedule, tax records, litigation disclosures, lien and judgment searches | Undisclosed tax arrears, liens, lawsuits, or secured assets | M&A attorney |
| Are Contracts, Leases, Licenses, and Permits Transferable, and How Should the Deal Be Structured? | Transfer consents, operating permissions, transaction structure, payment terms, and buyer protections | Leases, customer and supplier contracts, licenses, permits, IP records, draft purchase agreement | Key agreement or permit cannot transfer, or change-of-control terms threaten continuity | M&A attorney and tax advisor |
| Is the Business's Market Position and Competitive Outlook Sustainable? | Industry outlook, competition, pricing, disruption, and durable advantages | Market research, competitor pricing, customer reviews, industry reports | Declining demand, rising price pressure, or disruptive market changes | Industry or commercial diligence advisor |
Turn These Nine Answers Into a Go or No-Go Decision
Score each answer before you negotiate tone. Clear means you have the document and it matches the story. Unclear means you are still waiting on a record you named. Concerning means the record conflicts with the pitch, or a person, contract, or cash need could break the deal after you wire funds.
Concerning items get a price, not a shrug. Cut the offer, hold cash in escrow, keep a seller note that can be offset, or tie part of the price to retention and collections. If two or three items are concerning and the seller will not share the risk, walk. You will feel the lost weeks less than you will feel a bad close.
Sequence the spend. Seller interviews, tax returns, bank statements, a customer list, and a lease read are cheap and should happen before a full quality-of-earnings report or a long legal review. Expensive work is how you confirm a business that already looks coherent, not how you discover that the owner is the business.
If you are new to this, do not invent the sequence from listings. Our 10-Day Business Buying Launch is the first step for newcomers, and it is where our top dealmakers started. It teaches creative deal structuring before you are staring at a live seller. Mentors in the community can review an active deal while you still have room to reprice it. Dealmaker Academy teaches the same customer verification process our founder runs before putting real money into an acquisition: a customer interview, a concentration analysis, a contract review, and a retention-risk assessment. That is the work that turns a charming seller into a go or a no.
Scoring a deal is a form of how leaders make strategic choices. You decide what you will not accept, then you pay only for what the documents support. Bring the nine scores to the next seller call. If the concerning column is still full after the cheap checks, you already have your answer.
Dealmaker Wealth Society teaches acquisition entrepreneurs how to source, diligence, and structure small-business purchases, including the questions that should be answered before a letter of intent becomes a closing. The training covers deal structuring, due diligence, and the transition terms that keep risk from landing only on the buyer. Visit Dealmaker Wealth Society to see the programs and start with a sequence you can use on the next business you are asked to believe in.
From the Dealmaker Blog

















